• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Home
  • About Us
  • All Posts
  • Ghee Reviews
  • Shop
Pure Indian Foods, The Ghee Spoon Blog

Pure Indian Foods, The Ghee Spoon Blog

A collection of recipes and videos

The West has Bastardized Soy

August 11, 2022 by Pure Indian Foods Leave a Comment

OPINION
By Alana Sugar, Certified Nutritionist

There’s no substitute for the real thing.

What’s up with so much misinformation out there about food? With all the conflicting information out there, it could drive a person crazy, and I personally find it incredibly frustrating. Take the Mediterranean Diet for example: For years, I’ve studied the benefits of the Mediterranean diet, a diet loaded with legumes, olive oil, whole grains, fruits, veggies, red wine, and full-fat dairy. It’s a diet that is equally as rich as it is nutritious.

Yet inevitably, I continue to run into articles from yet another “leading health expert” who will tell us all about how to follow this ancient diet – and yet substitute some of the core parts with the Westernized version. It will go “eat your beans, your fruit, your veggies; add a little olive oil, have a small glass of wine and then enjoy some fat free yogurt or low fat cheese.” WHAATT????

Let me explain.

You see, fat-free dairy products are not the REAL, WHOLE FOOD version of diary that is a part of the Mediterranean diet. People in these areas would never, ever consider eating fat free yogurt or low-fat cheese – it’s not natural or particularly healthy. Furthermore, the “health expert” recommendations of legumes, fruits, veggies are right on, but the olive oil is consumed in far greater amounts than “a little,” and I can tell you first hand that a small glass of wine is more than “a little” inaccurate. As far as the low-to-no-fat dairy — that comes basically out of nowhere in this time-space reality. And I rarely if ever see mention of lamb, sausage, eggs, chicken, goats and guinea fowl.

My point being that the Mediterranean diet is about elegance and abundance of food… natural, grown in or raised on healthy soil. It’s rich and oozing with culture and art. Any attempt to make it less or basterdize any of it is… well, unsavory at the very least.

Whilst hanging out in Sicily—relaxing and enjoying the food, people, and sunshine on the Mediterranean—I was very busy people-watching. Now, I’ve always been a people watcher. But I’m more the type of watch-what-people-around-the-world-eat-when-you-travel-type people watcher. And let me tell you – these people were not eating whole wheat pizza crusts and whole wheat pasta and non-fat yogurt and low-fat cheese with torturous teeny tiny tastes of wine. NO! OK, YES, they do eat some whole grains like farro, cornmeal, and some whole grain breads but I mostly saw white flour bread that was golden in color from the durum wheat (semolina) flour they use – it’s mighty gorgeous and sooooo delicious! I never saw anyone eating fat free yogurt and low-fat cheese and they were certainly not on the menu in any of the restaurants I ate at. What about legumes? Yes, but often accompanied by meat or fish as part of a meal or in stews and soups. People enjoy a variety of food along the Mediterranean, including offal found in Sicilian street-food (guts, livers, kidneys, brains, and more), a variety of cheeses from sheep, goat and cow and more than just a smidgen of wine.

“So what’s your beef about soy?”

My next “beef” – no pun intended – is all about soy foods. There is this mindset among some here in the West that all soy is bad; and it is simply not true! I grew up in Hawaii on a mostly Japanese diet. My nephew has been living in Japan with his family for more than 10 years and has spent a good deal of time in Okinawa where the elderly are famous for living past the century mark (even to 110-112 years!). There are more centenarians in Okinawa than anywhere else in the world, and they, along with the Japanese, eat lots of soy foods… they love tofu, soymilk, edamame, natto, miso and shoyu (soy sauce). Soybeans are so respected and adored, they stand alone, as their own special food category. They don’t take the place of meat like they do in a vegan diet, but rather they are devoured alongside the meat/eggs/fish, including pork! And let me tell you that all of the pig is available for sale and put to good use … not just the little bit of ham hanging off the pig’s whatever or the bacon stuck to the pig’s ribs. NO! We’re talking EARS, FEET, LIVERS, HEADS … you get the picture!

So tell me, how is it possible for all these old people eating all this soy to be so healthy? They dance, they garden, they walk, they hike, they ride bicycles, they cook. But the one thing they don’t do is OVEREAT like we tend to do, The portions are often less and the foods are often lower in fat calories (tofu, edamame, rice, pickles, fish, fruit, veggies) and higher in starch (rice, noodles, bread, sweet potatoes (beloved in Okinawa). They eat plenty of eggs in Japan, along with lots of fish. The Okinawans love their pork, and soy is part of their daily diet, too, just like the Japanese. Soy is eaten as fermented natto (often in hot rice with raw egg and miso soup), tofu in miso soup but also steamed, sautéed, fried, boiled, etc. eaten with pickles, meats or fish, vegetables, white sticky rice and condiments and sauces. Plus, there’s homemade soymilk and the daily use of shoyu/soy sauce (which traditionally is the dark liquid that rises to the top of the miso as it vat-ferments over the years).

I wish we could just get the straight story on what other people are really eating without it having to be politically correct or aligned with someone else’s idea of a healthy diet. If we knew the truth of what a lot of these people around the world are really eating, it may well-surprise a lot of us Westerners. It may shock us, in fact!

Filed Under: Informative Articles

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

Recipe Search






About Us

Hi! We are Sandeep and Nalini Agarwal. We are passionate about sourcing and producing high-quality organic products that nourish, as well as taste delicious! We work with small farmers in both the United States and India. Since 1889, our family has been in the ghee business in India, and since 2008 have been making grassfed, organic ghee in the United States. We handcraft many spiced ghees and ayurvedic herbal ghees. Thank you for stopping by!

Recent Posts

  • Chana Samosa Chaat
  • Maple and Chai-Spiced Granola
  • Grain-Free Creamy Kitchari
  • Roasted Broccoli with Curry and Garam Masala
  • Simple, Nourishing Warm Milk Kefir
  • Easy Homemade Garlic Naan
  • Einkorn Chai-Spiced Chocolate Chip Cookies
  • Anjeer-Kefir Smoothie with Dates and Raw Honey
  • South Indian Summer Sambar
  • Dark Chocolate Cardamom Ice Cream
  • Ayurveda-Style Almond Milk with Spices
  • Comfort Custard
  • Quinoa Kitchari
  • Tropical Kokum Fruit
  • Food Additives and The Human Gut
  • Ghee Scrambled Eggs with Black Seed, Cumin and Curry Leaves
  • Mung Dal Buckwheat Kitchari
  • Indian-Spiced Chicken with Cashew Nuts
  • Pumpkin Streusel Muffins with Ghee and Spices
  • Wise-Woman Moon Milk with Shatavari Ghee and Fennel
  • Growing Up with Worcestershire Sauce
  • Heart-Warming Arjuna Moon Milk with Rose Petal Jam
  • Rest-Easy Brahmi-Ghee Moon Milk with Saffron
  • All-Around Magical Moon-Milk
  • Body-Boost Ashwagandha Moon Milk
  • Double Curry Dal with BEST HING EVER
  • Gluten-Free Flaxseed Muffins with Buttermilk, Ghee and Spices
  • Darjeeling Green Tea Latte
  • Darjeeling Iced Green Tea with Lime, Honey and Fruit
  • Ayurveda Cardamom-Citrus Immune Support Tea
  • Tandoori Seared Chicken Legs
  • Dave’s Stuffed Peppers
  • Indian Rice with Saffron, Spices and Cashews
  • Simple Chickpea Curry with Garlic Ghee
  • Pear Salad with Roasted Walnuts and Mango-Primal Dressing
  • Kick-Spiced Mini Turkey Muffins
  • What’s for Breakfast? Kapha Dosha
  • What’s for Breakfast? Pitta Dosha
  • What’s for Breakfast? Vata Dosha
  • Moringa Honey Coconut Ice Cream
  • Healing Carrot Ginger Soup with Ashwagandha Ghee
  • Munching on Mukhwas
  • Moringa, Date and Almond Treats
  • Organic Cardamom-Scented Maple Mukhwas
  • Classic Holiday Eggnog
  • No-Egg, No-Sugar Holiday “Nut-Nog”
  • Spiced Pears
  • Pumpkin Spice Bread with Honey-Cream Cheese Spread
  • Easy dabeli/samosa pinwheels (baked/air fried)
  • Basmati Rice and Oatmeal Breakfast Cereal
  • Red Palm Oil for cooking
  • The West has Bastardized Soy
  • Thandai, a Favorite Indian Cooling Summer Drink
  • Kitchari Cleanse – Panchakarma and Balance
  • Kabuli Chana and Kala Chana
  • Kabuli Chana Salad
  • Kala Chana Curry
  • Hawaiian Sandalwood
  • Re-thinking Avocado Oil
  • There’s No Fooling Mother Nature!
  • WHAT’S UP, DAAL?
  • Injipuli
  • Black Darjeeling? Green Darjeeling? Here’s the Difference
  • India’s Gift of Shampoo
  • Spinach Stew (Instant Pot Recipe)
  • Broccoli with Radicchio
  • Wild-Blueberry Spelt Pancakes
  • Kashmiri Deviled-Egg Appetizers
  • Beet Salad with Curry Dressing
  • Ghee-Roasted Carrots and Brussels Sprouts
  • Spicy-Nutty Chocolate Treats
  • Saffron-Curry Roast Chicken
  • Saffron Butter with Fresh Herbs
  • Whole Grain Ginger Kitchari
  • Mango Muse
  • Italian Style Zucchini Red Pepper Sauté
  • Easy Lentil Curry
  • Shamburak: Kurdish Meat Hand Pie – Great for leftovers!
  • Gluten-Free Banana-Oatmeal-Chocolate-Chip Cookies Using Digestive Ghee
  • Homemade Biscuits
  • Popcorn on Stove
  • Sprouted Mung Beans
  • Okroshka Soup
  • A Word About the Quality of Our Turmeric
  • Why you’ve never tasted the world’s most delicious mango
  • Saffron Fish Soup
  • Kashmiri-Saffron Risotto Alla Milanese
  • Almond Saffron Halwa
  • Onepot Kashmiri Saffron Kheer
  • What does it mean to be Demeter Certified Biodynamic®?
  • Twice-Cooked Spiced Cauliflower
  • Kashmiri Saffron: the world’s most precious spice
  • 25 Uses for Jaggery
  • Sweet Potato Hummus with Artichokes and Black Sesame Seeds
  • Open-Faced Cucumber Cream Cheese Sandwiches
  • Grilled Sesame Tuna Steaks
  • Vegan Tofu “Cheese” Pancakes with Mango Dip
  • Roasted Beet Hummus with Feta and Black Sesame Seeds
  • Spinach, Feta and Sundried-Tomato Muffins
  • Baked Pumpkin with Cheese, Thyme and Sesame Seeds

Footer

Pure Indian Foods
New Jersey

  • Disclaimer

Search

Copyright © 2025 Pure Indian Foods